Best Life Insurance for People Over 50: Compare Top Providers

Best Life Insurance for People Over 50: Compare Top Providers

People over age 50 often look for the same things in life insurance as anyone else. Pricing gets more expensive as we age, however, and coverage needs may change as our children become independent adults.

Investopedia’s extensive research has found Nationwide to be the best overall life insurance company for those who are applying for a new policy in their 50s. It offers many different types of policies and riders as well as affordable rates and a stand-out final expense policy.

We researched 45 companies in this category and made our picks based on 70 criteria, including customer satisfaction, financial strength, and policy types. Our comparison and research can provide you with insights into selecting the best coverage and the best insurer to suit your needs.

Best Life Insurance for People Over 50: Compare Top Providers

  • Best Overall, Best for Living Benefits, Best for Final Expense Insurance: Nationwide
  • Best for Term Life Insurance: Protective
  • Best for Whole Life Insurance: Lafayette
  • Best for Dividends: MassMutual
  • Best for Financial Stability: State Farm
  • Best for No-Medical-Exam Life Insurance: Penn Mutual
  • Best for Cheap Term, Best for Seniors: Thrivent

TIP

Compare life insurance quotes with our partner Covr Financial from multiple providers before buying.

BEST OVERALLBEST FOR LIVING BENEFITSBEST FOR FINAL EXPENSE INSURANCE:Nationwide

Nationwide Pet Insurance
  • Financial Strength Rating: A+
  • Complaint rate: Much better than expected for company size

Best Overall

Nationwide is a great life insurance company for people in their 50s for many of the same reasons it tops our overall list of the best life insurance companies. It’s financially strong, garners relatively few customer complaints, and offers the most policy types of all the companies Investopedia researched. It has one of the biggest selections of riders, too. Plus, you can buy up to $1.5 million of coverage without a medical exam and get an instant decision.

Best for Living Benefits

Nationwide includes three living benefits riders for free with many policies. These riders, also known as accelerated death benefits, let you use your death benefit while you’re alive if you develop a terminal, chronic, or critical illness. You can also add a long-term-care rider. You have to pay for that, but many competitors don’t even offer such a rider, and none include it for free.

Best for Final Expense Insurance

Nationwide offers final expense insurance with up to $50,000 in coverage. Most other companies Investopedia researched limit final expense coverage to $35,000 or less.

Pros
  • Outstanding selection of product types and riders

  • Superior financial strength rating (A+)

  • 3 living benefits included in many policies

  • Very few customer complaints to state regulators

  • High maximum coverage limit for final expense insurance

Cons
  • No online claims or live chat

  • Whole life insurance doesn’t pay dividends

  • Men over 49 and women over 54 can’t get a 30-year term policy

BEST FOR TERM LIFE INSURANCE:Protective

protective life insurance logo
  • Financial Strength Rating: A+
  • Complaint rate: Better than expected for company size

Protective has some of the lowest premiums for term life insurance for 55- and 65-year-olds in Investopedia’s study. It issues policies to applicants up to age 80, with terms as long as 35 years for 50-year-olds.

Pros
  • Affordable term premiums for people over 50

  • 35-year terms for 50-year-olds

  • No max coverage for term life

  • Low customer complaint level relative to its size

  • Offers online quotes and application

Cons
  • No final expense insurance

  • No live chat

BEST FOR WHOLE LIFE INSURANCE:Lafayette

Lafayette Life Insurance
  • Financial Strength Rating: A+
  • Complaint rate: Much better than expected for company size

Lafayette is the winner of our overall best whole life insurance list and the top whole life provider for people in this age group. It offers seven types of whole life insurance policies with expansive coverage limits, including one final expense policy. You also receive three accelerated death benefits for no extra cost. 

Pros
  • Offers many types of whole life policies with high coverage limits

  • Received fewer customer complaints than expected, given its size

  • Includes living benefits riders on some policies

Cons
  • No online quotes or applications

  • No live chat

  • Doesn’t operate in New York State

BEST FOR DIVIDENDS:MassMutual

MassMutual
  • Financial Strength Rating: A++
  • Complaint rate: Much better than expected for company size

According to Investopedia’s examination of 45 companies, MassMutual’s whole life policies paid the highest life insurance dividend rate on the market. Dividends are never guaranteed, but MassMutual has paid them every year since 1869.

Pros
  • Market-leading dividend interest rate

  • Whole life policies available up to age 90

  • Stellar customer complaint record 

  • Excellent rank in customer satisfaction survey

Cons
  • No online quotes

  • No online applications

  • Doesn’t offer live chat

BEST FOR FINANCIAL STABILITY:State Farm

State Farm
  • Financial Strength Rating: A++
  • Complaint rate: Much better than expected for company size

State Farm has an A++ financial strength grade from the credit rating agency AM Best, the highest rating possible. Only six other insurers we reviewed received the same rating.

Pros
  • Superior financial strength

  • Ranked No. 1 in J.D. Power customer satisfaction survey

  • Few customer complaints, relative to its size

  • Wide selection of policy types

  • Offers a return-of-premium term rider

Cons
  • No free riders

  • Low coverage limit for no-medical-exam policies

  • No online claims or live chat

BEST FOR NO-MEDICAL-EXAM LIFE INSURANCE:Penn Mutual

Penn Mutual
  • Financial Strength Rating: A+
  • Complaint rate: Much better than expected for company size

You can buy a no-medical-exam life insurance policy from Penn Mutual with a death benefit as large as $10 million. That’s the highest limit for this type of policy that Investopedia’s research uncovered.

Pros
  • Large coverage limit for no-medical-exam policies

  • One of the best complaint records in the industry

  • Offers a variety of life insurance policies

  • Whole life insurance pays dividends

Cons
  • Doesn’t sell final expense insurance

  • No online quotes or applications

  • No live chat

BEST FOR CHEAP TERMBEST FOR SENIORS:Thrivent

Thrivent
  • Financial Strength Rating: A++
  • Complaint rate: Much better than expected for company size

Best for Cheap Term

Thrivent’s term life insurance premiums for people over 50 were the lowest Investopedia found when gathering quotes for 45 companies. 

Best for Seniors

Thrivent accepts applicants at older ages than many of its competitors do, which makes it a good option for life insurance shoppers age 65 and older. 

Pros
  • Lowest term life premiums for people over 50

  • High maximum issue age on many policies

  • Strongest financial stability rating available

  • Best NAIC complaint index of the companies Investopedia researched

Cons
  • Only Christians and their spouses can apply

  • Few riders available

  • No final expense insurance

  • No online applications 

Why You Should Trust Us

All of Investopedia’s life insurance reviews are based on extensive research and analysis by a team of expert researchers, editors, and writers. To create this list of the best life insurance companies for people over 50, we collected data on dozens of criteria from 45 companies. The criteria helped us score each company’s costs, coverage options, financial stability, and other features and come up with objective evaluations to help you choose the best provider for you.

Investopedia has been publishing trustworthy financial information since 1999 and has been reviewing life insurance companies since 2020. 

Why Should People Over 50 Consider Getting Life Insurance?

People over age 50 should consider getting life insurance if they have a spouse, children, or other dependents who rely on them financially. It can be useful if you want to assist your spouse or child in paying off a mortgage, covering funeral costs, supporting your favorite charity, or funding a grandchild’s education after you’ve passed away. 

But life insurance can be costly as you get older. When insurance companies determine an individual's premium, they’ll look at factors like age, health status, gender, medical history, and more. So life insurance premiums for a healthy 30-year-old will generally cost less than premiums for a 50-year-old who has a higher risk of death.3

When narrowing down what type of life insurance to purchase, you’ll want to think about why you need life insurance,  how much coverage you want, and how much you’re willing to pay.

Types of Life Insurance For People Over 50

Term Life Insurance

Term life insurance offers policyholders coverage for a set period of time (typically between 10 and 30 years). If the policyholder passes away while they’re covered, their beneficiaries will receive a death benefit. However, if they die after their insurance has expired, the death benefit won’t be paid out. Term life insurance is much more affordable than other types of lifelong permanent coverage.

For people who have temporary financial obligations, like a mortgage, term life insurance may be a better option than permanent life insurance. Someone might purchase a term life insurance policy that ends shortly after they’ve paid off their mortgage. If they pass away while still owing the mortgage, their beneficiary can use the death benefit to help pay off the remaining debt. 

Term life insurance can also replace your income if you pass away while still working. You can buy a policy that lasts until you retire. People over 50 might still plan on working a decade or longer and could set up term coverage that lasts until they retire.

Plus, there are some term life insurance policies that offer policyholders the option of converting their policy to a permanent life insurance policy without undergoing an additional medical exam. Convertible policies can be beneficial for people who initially opt for term life because it’s more affordable but want the option of switching to permanent life insurance later on.

Whole Life Insurance

Whole life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance. It provides lifelong coverage and includes cash value that policyholders can withdraw, borrow from, or use to cover premiums. With whole life insurance, premiums and the death benefit are fixed. Additionally, the interest rate that policyholders receive on cash value is fixed, which means you receive a guaranteed return on your money.

Whole life insurance can make sense for needs that never go away, like covering your final expenses or leaving an inheritance. You could also use whole life insurance to build up cash value that you could spend in retirement. 

Final Expense Insurance

Final expense insurance is a kind of permanent life insurance policy that provides a smaller death benefit, typically between $10,000 and $50,000.4 In other words, just enough to cover a funeral and other final expenses. Final expense life insurance has fixed premiums and can include cash value.

These policies typically do not require a medical exam. In exchange, they are more expensive than a regular whole life policy with the same death benefit. There could also be a waiting period before the coverage begins, such as one to three years after the date of purchase. If you pass away during the waiting period, your heirs usually get the premiums back but not the death benefit.

Unlike the name suggests, final expense life insurance does not have to be used exclusively to cover costs associated with a funeral—beneficiaries can use the funds as they see fit, whether that’s to pay off a mortgage or medical expenses.

Final expense life insurance may also be a better option for people who prefer not having to undertake a medical exam for underwriting—since the death benefit is smaller, the underwriting process is more straightforward.

Universal Life Insurance

Universal life insurance is also a type of permanent life insurance that has cash value. Yet unlike whole life insurance, which has fixed premiums and a fixed death benefit, universal life insurance offers more flexibility—policyholders pay flexible premiums and can adjust their death benefit.

With universal life insurance, premiums increase as a policyholder ages to make up for the higher insurance costs. You are supposed to build up cash value while younger to help cover the premiums later in life.5

Universal life is less expensive than whole life insurance. It can be a more affordable way for someone over 50 to buy permanent coverage. However, they must budget carefully to ensure they build enough cash value for the higher future premiums.

Pros & Cons of Life Insurance for People Over 50

Pros
  • Applicants may still be eligible for plans with a large payout

  • Wide selection of plans available

  • Can provide living benefits in retirement

Cons
  • Premiums are more costly

  • Applicants may be in poorer health

  • Qualifying can take more work

Pros Explained

  • Applicants may still be eligible for plans with a large payout: While you’ll pay more for a life insurance plan over age 50 than you would at age 35, you can still enroll in life insurance plans that offer generous coverage, provided you are healthy enough to qualify.
  • Wide selection of plan types still available: People over 50 have a range of financial needs. Most life insurance products should still be available, ranging from temporary term to permanent policies for lifelong coverage.
  • Can provide living benefits in retirement: Some policies include riders that pay out while you are still alive if you develop a chronic or terminal illness, so you have more money for medical bills. You could also buy life insurance that helps pay for long-term care in a nursing home. Plus, cash-value policies build savings you can use while alive.

Cons Explained

  • Premiums are more costly: As you get older, your risk of death increases—insurance companies will generally charge higher premiums for older applicants.
  • Applicants may be in poorer health: Generally, health declines as you age, so you may be in worse health in your 50s than you were 20 years earlier. This means that if you have poor health and opt for a plan that requires a medical exam, you could end up paying some hefty premiums. 
  • Qualifying can take more work: Life insurers tend to have tougher medical underwriting as people get older. Someone over 50 may need to pass more health testing hurdles, such as seeing a doctor for a full physical or taking an EKG. If you have a pre-existing health condition, you may need to apply with several insurers to find one that is more accepting of your situation.

How We Chose the Best Life Insurance Companies for People Over 50

Investopedia’s list of the best life insurance companies for people over 50 is based on extensive research into the top providers. We first commissioned a consumer survey about life insurance and consulted information about market share and popularity to understand which companies to consider. We then removed providers who didn’t meet our baseline standards for online transparency, financial strength, and customer satisfaction, leaving us with 45 companies to research further. 

Between May 20 and July 3, 2024, our experts gathered 3,150 data points related to 70 criteria. The data came from company webpages, media representatives, rating agencies (AM BestNAIC, and J.D. Power), and customer service calls.

Then, staff editors and research analysts created a quantitative model that scores each company based on six major categories, which we weighted as such:

  • Policy Features and Riders: 34%
  • Application and Online Service Features: 20%
  • Policy Types: 16%
  • Cost: 14%
  • Customer Satisfaction: 10%
  • Financial Stability: 6%

Featured Post

Can You Afford a Home? Here's What You Need to Earn in the 50 Biggest Cities

KEY TAKEAWAYS Experts recommend spending no more than 30% of your income on housing costs. We’ve calculated the income needed to afford a me...

Popular Posts